Scarlett Thomas’ our Tragic Universe was the last book I read this year and perhaps appropriately so, as the book itself is a sort of reflection on storytelling and how the writer relates to the process. The heroine, Meg, is a ghostwriter of YA Fiction who is stuck in a dumpy house that is a too humid with a slacker boyfriend who is too whiny and immature. Thomas chronicles Meg’s growing unhappiness with such detail that at times the sadness leapt off the pages and seeped into my own brain. Set along the shore in either New England or in the UK somewhere, the quiet town seems to be constantly drizzling and dreary but populated with eccentric and retirement aged characters.
It’s fine writing but it got to be a little much reading about one woman’s unhappiness until about 70% of the way in which is when the book really hits its stride- a strange twist of fate intrudes on her real life in the form of a mysterious ship in a bottle and a possibly supernatural wolf-monster.

This book seemed to be running on two tracks- one which concerns itself with the details of her depressing life populated with past-due bills and failed relationships, and another which reads like a highly philosophized discourse on the nature of reality. The reader gets treated to a helping of Zen koans and theories of an afterlife called Second World where we are all dead but don’t know it yet (see 1990 film, Sixth Sense)
These two universes, one tragically mundane and the other where the supernatural is possible, intersect but not the way you expect it to. Meg doesn’t get sucked into a world of magic and run off having adventures. Instead, she talks at length about the possibility of the extraordinary and works those thoughts and conversations back into her everyday life. In that way, she infuses her dissatisfied life with a spark of something grander.
Spoiler alert: The best part of the book isn’t about how Meg dumps her boyfriend, moves into a new place, and picks up new hobbies. That’s chick-lit fare (no offense to chick-lit readers). As previously mentioned, the book saves itself in the third act from becoming the chronicles of a middle-life crisis by evolving into a meta-fictional work about how writing and life is rarely linear with neat and tidy endings*
Bottom Line: While being well-written, the story and main character kinda dragged. The ideas touched upon in Our Tragic Universe and interesting and novel; they shine through what would have been an otherwise debby-downer of a novel. Cerebral but hard to connect with.
Rating: 2.5 out of 5 ships in a bottle
(insert .jpg of half a ship)

*What I felt was the point of this novel was that there doesn’t necessarily have to be a point. A story can be a story without a conventional arc and plot structure (introduction to hero, dilemma, overcoming evil, ending). One of Meg’s hippie friends expands this concept of the “storyless story” and in fact, that’s what Our Tragic Universe comes off across as. However, one peril of this approach is that it’s harder for the reader to emotionally invest in such a story. I honestly didn’t care if Meg was any happier by the end but I found the journey from page 1 to page 425 interesting.